How I Met Your Mother: All the plot holes, mistakes, and unanswered questions

[post_page_title]When it comes to Ted and Natalie[/post_page_title]

In season 1, episode 4, Ted talks about Natalie, who is a girl from his past. He explains that the two of them dated three years ago, and he actually broke up with her on her birthday.

When it comes to Ted and Natalie

The episode claims that the two have not seen each other for three years and is clear about that. During this episode, Ted dates her again for three weeks and repeats his actions of breaking up with her on her birthday. This was in October 2005, making the original breakup October 2002.

Recommended For You